Colorado Credit Unions

CO Credit Unions

2025-Q3 66 Credit Unions

Colorado Credit Unions Show Mixed Performance with Steady Profitability Amid Membership Challenges

Colorado credit unions demonstrated resilient financial performance in Q3 2025, maintaining stable ROA at 0.52% while improving NIM to 3.58% from 3.53% quarter-over-quarter and 3.45% year-over-year. Asset growth accelerated to 2.63% from 2.09% last quarter, outpacing the national benchmark by 9 basis points. However, member growth remained negative at -1.39%, though improving from -1.68% in Q2. The credit unions shifted toward safer assets with certificate concentrations rising to 26.32% while maintaining sound capital positions despite lagging national net worth levels.

Key Insights

Year-over-Year Changes

Share Certificate Concentration (%) (Absolute)
2024-Q3 2025-Q3
24.53% → 26.32% (+7.30%)
Net Interest Margin (NIM) (Absolute)
2024-Q3 2025-Q3
3.45% → 3.58% (+0.13%)
First Mortgage Concentration (%) (Absolute)
2024-Q3 2025-Q3
29.19% → 29.42% (+0.77%)
Indirect Auto Concentration (%) (Absolute)
2024-Q3 2025-Q3
13.51% → 12.38% (-8.37%)
Net Worth Ratio (Absolute)
2024-Q3 2025-Q3
12.18% → 12.18% (+0.00%)

Quarter-over-Quarter Changes

Asset Growth (YoY) (Absolute)
2025-Q2 2025-Q3
2.09% → 2.63% (+0.54%)
Share Certificate Concentration (%) (Absolute)
2025-Q2 2025-Q3
26.00% → 26.32% (+1.22%)
Deposit Growth (YoY) (Absolute)
2025-Q2 2025-Q3
2.60% → 3.02% (+0.41%)
Member Growth (YoY) (Absolute)
2025-Q2 2025-Q3
-1.68% → -1.39% (+0.29%)
Net Interest Margin (NIM) (Absolute)
2025-Q2 2025-Q3
3.53% → 3.58% (+0.05%)

Key Metrics

Return on Assets

0.52%

YoY
26 basis points below national
Profitability

Net Interest Margin

3.58%

YoY
14 basis points below national
Profitability

Asset Growth

2.63%

YoY
Growth

Member Growth

-1.39%

Growth

Delinquency Rate

0.80%

YoY
Risk

Net Worth Ratio

12.18%

Risk

AMR Growth

3.66%

Engagement
Insufficient historical data for trend visualization

Deposit Growth

3.02%

YoY
Growth
Insufficient historical data for trend visualization

Loan Growth

-0.43%

YoY
Growth

Member Engagement

Member Growth (YoY %)

Member engagement remained challenged with growth at -1.39% in Q3 2025, though accelerating from -1.68% in Q2 and contrasting sharply with 1.44% growth a year ago. The cohort continues to underperform the national benchmark by 78 basis points, indicating persistent membership acquisition difficulties.

Profitability

Return on Assets (%)

Net Interest Margin (%)

Profitability showed steady improvement with NIM increasing to 3.58% from 3.53% quarter-over-quarter and 3.45% year-over-year. ROA remained stable at 0.52% across both timeframes, though trailing the national benchmark by 26 basis points, reflecting consistent but modest earnings performance.

Growth

Asset Growth (YoY %)

Member Growth (YoY %)

Growth momentum accelerated with assets expanding 2.63% from 2.09% last quarter, surpassing national levels by 9 basis points. Deposit growth accelerated to 3.02% from 2.60% quarter-over-quarter, outpacing national benchmarks by 70 basis points, while loan growth remained stable at -0.43%.

Risk & Credit Quality

Delinquency Rate (%)

Net Worth Ratio (%)

Risk metrics remained well-controlled with delinquencies stable at 0.80% quarter-over-quarter, though up from 0.71% year-over-year. Net worth increased to 12.18% from 12.10% last quarter while remaining flat year-over-year, staying 1.50 percentage points below national benchmarks.

Portfolio Mix

First Mortgage (%)

Indirect Auto (%)

Share Certificates (%)

Portfolio composition shifted toward conservative positioning with certificate concentrations rising to 26.32% from 26.00% quarter-over-quarter and 24.53% year-over-year. First mortgage exposure increased modestly to 29.42% while indirect auto lending declined to 12.38%, reflecting risk-conscious asset allocation strategies.

Strategic Implications

  • Implement targeted member acquisition campaigns to reverse negative growth trends and close national performance gaps.
  • Leverage strong deposit growth momentum to expand lending capacity and improve loan-to-deposit ratios.
  • Consider rebalancing certificate-heavy portfolio to optimize yield while maintaining conservative risk profile.
  • Focus on operational efficiency improvements to bridge ROA gap with national benchmarks.
  • Develop member retention strategies to stabilize membership base before pursuing aggressive growth initiatives.

How does your credit union compare?

See where you stand against 4,800+ credit unions nationwide

Free instant access · No registration required

Notable Patterns

How This Cohort Compares to National

Assets Per Member (annual) is 179.1pp above national

Loan To Member Ratio (Quarterly) is 40.6pp below national

Loan To Member Ratio (Annual) is 8.2pp below national

First Mortgage Share is 7.7pp above national

Certificate Pct is 6.7pp above national

Data Quality Notes

5 metric(s) had extreme values filtered using MAD-based, z-score > 5.0.

Asset Growth (YoY) (Absolute) 3 CU(s) excluded
Raw average: 6.15% → Cleaned average: 2.63%
View excluded credit unions
Deposit Growth (YoY) (Absolute) 3 CU(s) excluded
Raw average: 6.92% → Cleaned average: 3.02%
View excluded credit unions
Member Growth (YoY) (Absolute) 2 CU(s) excluded
Raw average: 1.64% → Cleaned average: -1.39%
View excluded credit unions
Loan Growth (YoY) (Absolute) 2 CU(s) excluded
Raw average: 2.32% → Cleaned average: -0.43%
View excluded credit unions
Total Delinquency Rate (60+ days) (Absolute) 2 CU(s) excluded
Raw average: 0.93% → Cleaned average: 0.80%
View excluded credit unions
Back to Analysis
Link copied to clipboard!